The IMF's Controversial Response to the Asian Financial Crisis
By Paul Brothwood In 2004, my dissertation reached a confident conclusion about the International Monetary Fund. The IMF had provided emergency finance, supported reform and helped the affected economies recover. I accepted that some of its policies caused harm, but I still wrote that its critics were wrong. Recovery appeared to settle the argument. The evidence inside my own dissertation was less certain. A Thai government finance official who answered my questions said the IMF's early measures produced a sharp economic slowdown and left no room for an economic stimulus. The same official also credited later reforms with improving corporate governance, transparency and accountability. That contradiction is the right place to start. The IMF supplied finance when private lenders were withdrawing and national reserves were running down. Its support helped prevent a deeper collapse. Some early conditions also intensified recession and social hardship. Those two findings belong i...